From High Turnover to High Retention: Questions Every Leader Should Be Asking

Turnover shows up in reports, and instability shows up everywhere else. It’s felt in missed goals, low engagement, and constant disruptions. Workforce instability—whether it’s high turnover or people staying but disengaged—isn’t just the cost of doing business. It’s a signal that something deeper needs to change. Thriving teams don’t come from just keeping people—they come from creating the conditions for them to succeed. Asking simple, thought-provoking questions can help leaders take meaningful steps to make positive impacts.

In many organizations, especially in logistics, manufacturing, healthcare, and retail, turnover has become a persistent reality. Leaders quietly accept rates of 30%, 40%, 50%, or even higher, assuming it’s just the nature of the industry. But here’s the truth: it doesn’t have to be that way.

High turnover isn’t just a staffing issue. It’s a systems issue.

Turnover Is More Than a Metric—It’s a Symptom

Behind every resignation is a story:

  • A missed opportunity to lead.
  • An unresolved obstacle.
  • A breakdown in trust.

When teams churn, performance suffers. So do culture, morale, and continuity. The cost of replacing a frontline employee may seem like a line item, but the ripple effect- missed output, lower engagement, safety risks, wasted training -can’t be ignored. And yet, many organizations continue to treat workforce instability like it’s a weather pattern: unpredictable, unchangeable, and out of their control.

What’s Causing the Disconnect?

Often, the problem lies in how organizations are structured to support people.  Human Resources carries the responsibility of engagement, development, and compliance.  Operations drives performance, efficiency, and output. They both care about people, but often do not work as one team.  This separation creates misaligned goals, fragmented communication, and a lack of shared ownership over workforce health.

The Missed Opportunity: Alignment

When HR and Operations come together—sharing insights, setting joint goals, and aligning their efforts—a shift happens:

  • People feel supported and seen and challenged to perform
  • Leaders receive tools that develop trust, not just track performance
  • Problems get solved closer to the work, with participation from all levels
  • Instability becomes something that can be measured, managed, and improved

This isn’t just a new way of working, it’s a smarter one. One where frontline engagement and leadership growth aren’t separate efforts, but part of the same system.

The Real Cost of Instability—and the Opportunity Hiding in Plain Sight

Turnover is expensive—but that’s just the surface.

TrailPath’s research shows that workplace instability isn’t only about people leaving; it’s about what happens when they stay but can’t thrive. Untrained team members, reactive leadership, wasted time, safety issues, and inconsistent performance all add up.

Here’s what the numbers say:

  • A single frontline turnover event costs between $7,500 and $15,000
  • An organization with 1,000 frontline team members and 50% annual turnover spends an estimated $5 million per year—just in direct HR costs
  • Up to 50% of frontline supervisors’ time is spent reacting to chaos instead of leading their teams

And these are only the measurable costs. The true price of instability includes hidden impacts to safety, quality, customer satisfaction, lost productivity, and cultural breakdowns.

 

“The cost of workplace instability may be the largest cost of the whole bunch. It is real, it is big, but it is not easily measurable.”
TrailPath White Paper: Compensation & Workplace Stability

Now flip the script: when turnover is reduced and participation rises, so does productivity. This isn’t hypothetical—it’s what happens when people are stable, supported, engaged, and thriving.

 

What Stability Actually Looks Like

Organizations that address this head-on are seeing results:

  • Turnover rates decline dramatically
  • Teams participate more, offering input, taking ownership, staying longer
  • Leaders develop new habits that reinforce trust and accountability
  • Cultures begin to stabilize, creating environments where people want to stay

Work becomes more human. And because of that, business outcomes get better.

What Questions Should Leaders Be Asking?

You don’t need to overhaul your entire structure. But you can start by asking:

  1. Where are HR and Operations working toward different goals?
  2. Do your frontline leaders know how to engage beyond task management?
  3. Are you gathering feedback from your teams and acting on it in real time?
  4. Are people staying because they have to, or because they believe in where you're going?

When you begin to answer these questions honestly, you create the foundation for real improvement.

It’s Time to Rethink the Narrative

Turnover isn’t just about recruiting harder. It’s about building systems of leadership, trust, and participation that are scalable, so they survive beyond one good manager or one strong HR initiative.

Because the real cost of turnover isn’t just financial, it’s cultural.

And the organizations that choose to address it now will be the ones leading the future.

NxtPath logo

NxtPath™ is an interconnected technology platform that drives improved organizational decision making, scales leader behaviors and increases team member participation to build Meaningful Employment Environments™. Click here to learn more.

More Articles